Help With Sights Please

[Bookworm007]

So this year I decided to start hunting muzzleloader for deer just as a trial basis. I didn't want to sink big money into a gun that I may or may not use a lot so I went with a Traditions Tracker. I knew it was cheap but it was simple and easy to use. One of the cheapest parts was the sights which have already broken and were a pain to sight in (no fine adjustments).  So I need new sights!

Two options while staying WA legal:
 
1.) Replace them with another set of fiber optic open sights (better quality of course)

or

2.) Put a set of peep sights on.

Any recommendations? 

[winshooter88]

Since you don't want to spend any more money than necessary, it seems reasonable to fix the open sights. Peep sights in my experience give a better and more accurate sight picture, but they will be more expensive. If you knew that you were going to keep and use the gun then I'd go for the peep sights. Of course if you sell the rifle later then you might get more for it with the peep sights on it. 

[Bookworm007]

I have already decided to keep the gun. It is fun to shoot, and I greatly enjoy having less hunters to contend with. I didn't want to buy an expensive rifle at first.  Peeps are more expensive but I guess I looking to find out if they are better choice? Are they worth the extra cost? Do they still perform in low light conditions?

[bendotti]

I went with the truglo muzzle brit ghost globe and ghost rear peep I love them awsome glow even at low lite

[oneshot12]

the true glo  sights are nice have a set on my 54 Remington   .just  make sure not to have anything happen to the front sight  snaps pretty easy  . have been thinking of switch over to a peep sight myself   and making sure the front blade is covered  the true glo  sights dont have a front sight hood guard   but  would  recommend you find what best suits your shooting stile   and what you like before you make any changes

[Bookworm007]

the true glow sights are they metal or plastic? They say CNC machined but the finish looks like plastic? And the ghost ring set up is very interesting is the idea to be a cross between a peep and open sights? I narrowed my selection down to these too options. I have used peep sights before but only in target shooting not hunting wasn't sure how good there were for moving targets.

http://www.truglo.com/pc_product_detail.asp?key=5D8DA3413D8F4F2B88BD0B88A808A156&catid=8C1129845AF1419E9350FF4C84415FEA

and

http://www.cabelas.com/product/Williams-Adjustable-Rear-Peep-Sight/740049.uts?WT.tsrc=CRR&WT.mc_id=crrdtfd

thoughts? all metal construction would be nice as I tend to go through hairy brush and would hate to bust a sight.

[oneshot12]

the true glo are  metal  and fit in the same place you existing sights are  the williams  can fit as far back  to where your first scope mount would go 

[Bookworm007]

So which would you choose? Williams or truglo?

[jrebel]

Williams....hands down, no comparison.  the Tru Glow were way to big and clunky for me and seem to cover up the entire animal at longer range.  I love my williams.

[Bookworm007]

Williams it is!!! The adjustments look better on them too. I will be sure to report how they do when they arrive

[bendotti]

This is my setup

[jrebel]

This is my setup

Shot with one of those once and didn't like it.  The peep is way to thick and fiber optic on the peep is not necessary.  I also did not like how big the front pin / shroud was....it covered the entire target (deer) at ranges must past 80 yards.  I could probably make it work if the front was just a fiber pin without the shroud. 

[Bookworm007]

This is my setup

Shot with one of those once and didn't like it.  The peep is way to thick and fiber optic on the peep is not necessary.  I also did not like how big the front pin / shroud was....it covered the entire target (deer) at ranges must past 80 yards.  I could probably make it work if the front was just a fiber pin without the shroud. 

Also that set up is no longer offered. Most likely for the reasons stated.

[Sabotloader]

So which would you choose? Williams or truglo?

Myself... I would go with the Williams setup on both ends of the barrel.  Rear FP peep sight, with 1/4 min clicks, and on the front a Williams Ramp, fire sight, and Fire Sight Hood...  With the hood and looking through the peep you get the appearance that you might be looking through the a 1x scope.

[Runamuck]

I have set my Bighorn up just as Sabotloader suggested. Fantastic sighting combination! Great for these old eyes.
The Williams front fire sight is now green instead of red.
It's going to be next to impossible to take the old Thompson Renegade out after using these sights.