I have shot both types of broadheads from multiple companies and when it comes down to it the new fixed blades fly as well as field points. Reliability matters more to me and I have had expandables fail on me. The only fixed blade I have had problems with was a Crimson Talon, the blades are curved at ~56 degree angle. The second deer I shot with those the arrow made a 45 degree turn and completely missed vitals. Shot was from a treestand and I got the broadhead back after a buddy shot that same 150" whitetail during shotgun season. The new Toxic broad heads have similar curvature but seem like a better design.