Thanks guys for all the feedback. I'm really surprised to hear the issues with the eyelets and the stitching and that Hanwag wouldn't stand by their product. Every other review I have read raves about how awesome the Mountain Lights are and how much they love them. Like Forks said I am still tempted to go against the advice and still get them. It s a lot of money so I will do as everyone suggests and give Lathrop & Sons a call first. Maybe they have made improvements on the boots.
In my experience Lathrop has stood behind everything! Communications have been good, service has been good and they have made every attempt to make things right with me. I even tried to pay them for the extra pair of boots and they wouldn't take my payment information. The service was so good I felt guilty getting anything for free. And BTW I now have their foot beds in every single pair of hunting boots I own...they are GREAT! I will never waste my money on Super-Feet ever again.
I've worn my Mountain Lights quite a bit here in Washington. And the area I hunt for elk is pretty dang steep with a lot of slash piles to stumble through coming out in the dark. Not a single stitch problem yet! It's just those darn eyelets without the separate rivet. Unfortunately if I was to have them replaced with a Kennetrek type of eyelet the Goretex would be damaged. At least that's what my cobbler tells me. I will have that done once the Gore-Tex fails and they start to leak. Then I will have about the finest dry weather boots ever!