Free: Contests & Raffles.
Quote from: bobcat on May 20, 2016, 05:53:50 PMI think it's somewhat legitimate to call this elk a pet and to have a problem with the taking of this elk because of how tame it was. The reason it was this way is because it never lived in a GMU that was open to branch antler elk hunting. This was the only reason this bull survived to the age that he did. Nobody else killed him because it had always been illegal to do so. Until Tod Reichert came along.one of the bulls that hung out with bullwinkle was tranquilized this winter and was relocate to Joe watt feed lot. When the bull came to it walked out of the trailer looked at all the elk ran all the way to east side before breaking through the fence. He found his way home within less than a week. Hmmm tame?
I think it's somewhat legitimate to call this elk a pet and to have a problem with the taking of this elk because of how tame it was. The reason it was this way is because it never lived in a GMU that was open to branch antler elk hunting. This was the only reason this bull survived to the age that he did. Nobody else killed him because it had always been illegal to do so. Until Tod Reichert came along.
Quote from: kiticaashunter on May 20, 2016, 11:17:12 PM He is one of the most generous good people alive. And has done more for the elk than 95% of the hunters in this state combined. What more has he done than the bidder $1000 behind his bid wouldn't have done?
He is one of the most generous good people alive. And has done more for the elk than 95% of the hunters in this state combined.
Quote from: huntnphool on May 20, 2016, 11:20:37 PMQuote from: kiticaashunter on May 20, 2016, 11:17:12 PM He is one of the most generous good people alive. And has done more for the elk than 95% of the hunters in this state combined. What more has he done than the bidder $1000 behind his bid wouldn't have done?Well if you paid any attention, I believe it was last year he bid up his own bI'd by another 5k when it was clear there was not another bid coming in.
Wdfw could've saved time, money and resources and just called me and I would've came out and dropped those bulls for free.
Quote from: kiticaashunter on May 21, 2016, 12:00:13 AMQuote from: huntnphool on May 20, 2016, 11:20:37 PMQuote from: kiticaashunter on May 20, 2016, 11:17:12 PM He is one of the most generous good people alive. And has done more for the elk than 95% of the hunters in this state combined. What more has he done than the bidder $1000 behind his bid wouldn't have done?Well if you paid any attention, I believe it was last year he bid up his own bI'd by another 5k when it was clear there was not another bid coming in. Wow, I stand corrected, his $5k is indeed more for elk than 95% of the rest of the hunters in this state have done combined.
kiticaashunter,What you said the question was only means that the game enforcement officer said that in a firearms restricted unit even a disabled hunter could not use a rifle and would have to use a muzzleloader, since we don't know which unit he was told it was in, that does nothing to prove that he knew what unit the elk was located in. Also I was always told that ignorance of the law was no excuse.Partial quote from kitticaashunter's previous post."The true fact is at the time the only question in anobodys mind was could a rifle be used, or did it need to be a muzzleloader. So they did what we were tought 30 years ago in the fire arms safety course and called and asked the question. Mr. Grant said that it could not be killed with a rifle in that unit. Then was asked if it could because the hunter was disabled. He said he would figure it out. 16 minutes later (documented) he called back and told them they shouldn't use a rifle and muzzleloader was fine. That shows Grant knew the exact unit this was in."
Depending on the date when this "hunt" occurred, there is a antlerless hunt in that unit mid November until mid December. You could the WDFW office and say: I'm elk hunting and I'm not sure if I can hunt with a mod rifle or not, can you help me out? Response: Where are you? I'll check and call you back. Ring: You can hunt there but it's a firearms restricted area, so shotgun, muzzle loader or bow. Response: Thanks!Thing is the other elk that was shot in a "yard" was legal. This elk was not, ever! Oh yea, it was shot in a yard too!
Quote from: jmscon on May 21, 2016, 12:32:32 AMDepending on the date when this "hunt" occurred, there is a antlerless hunt in that unit mid November until mid December. You could the WDFW office and say: I'm elk hunting and I'm not sure if I can hunt with a mod rifle or not, can you help me out? Response: Where are you? I'll check and call you back. Ring: You can hunt there but it's a firearms restricted area, so shotgun, muzzle loader or bow. Response: Thanks!Thing is the other elk that was shot in a "yard" was legal. This elk was not, ever! Oh yea, it was shot in a yard too!Mr. Grant knew the exact bull that was was going to be taken. There was no trickery or word's twisted in this case. At the time he gave gave the good to go he was up for promotion. Since then he has gotten it and tried hard to distance himself from this. He is an honest guy and will tell the truth on the stand. And that will be that he double checked to make sure it was all good.
Quote from: bearpaw on May 18, 2016, 09:16:21 AMQuote from: HighCountryHunter88 on May 18, 2016, 08:46:08 AMQuote from: WAcoyotehunter on May 18, 2016, 07:19:33 AMQuote from: Branden on May 15, 2016, 10:07:07 AMI'm not going to comment on the legalities of it because I was not there nor the one that got supposed permission to hunt that area. I do have a problem though with the part about how it's bad to shoot an animal in a field. Zero difference then shooting a cat out of a tree. Neither one takes any skill yet 99% of the people on this site would jump at the chance to shoot a lion in a tree. The first thread on this issue was started because guys were saying it wasn't much of a hunt. Not that it was illegal. Then that started after a page or two. So for the guys that are saying it's not hunting get off your high horse. You do a lot of hound hunting Brandon??oooo you beat me to it!he likely has never cougar hunted....I've been lucky enough to do many different hunts, including hunts in several other countries, cougar hunting is still my favorite hunt. Some of the best cougar hunts have ended by taking photos and leaving the cat in the tree! The most rewarding part is watching the young hounds learn and develop into experienced lion hounds. Almost anyone can become successful in many types of hunting, but to be a top notch hound hunter requires incredible dedication by the hunter and a very sharp learning curve. After all the time and work to get good at hound hunting, you can take your dogs to field, search for days and sometimes weeks to find a good track, you and your dogs can experience the thrill of the hunt, hopefully you catch the cat and get photos of the hunted, and then you leave the hunted animal unharmed in the wild after experiencing the hunt of lifetime. Hunting really can't get any better than that!For those that choose to notch a cougar tag you then have some of the best meat in the woods!I've actually shot 4 lions in Washington. All without hounds. So yes I've hunted cats before. Let's say I was rich like some hunters are and a cat is on my bucket list. I hire the best outfitter I can find. Wait by the phone for a call once they get good snow in the area I'm hunting. Fly in, ride out with an outfitter and cut tracks right away. Get lucky and the cat is treed after a few minutes cause it had a kill next to the road. Hike the 200 yards off the road and shoot it out of the tree. Get my trophy pictures of me with my cat. Yes not all cat hunts are like that. But some are that easy. And some are way more physical. But at the end of the day most of the cats that get killed take absolutely zero skill from the guys doing the shooting. They pay money to a guy that trains dogs to tree animals. They follow the dogs and shoot an animal out of a tree. Absolutely zero skill on the shooters part. So you have a very good dog trainer, and a guy that pays money to shoot an animal out of a tree, and the actually hunters are the dogs. How about a guided whitetail hunt with bait? You pay the money, ride out to the blind on the ATV. Wait for the feeder to kick on. Once it does here come the deer and bam you just killed a trophy whitetail. Again zero skill involved. Zero effort involved.
Quote from: HighCountryHunter88 on May 18, 2016, 08:46:08 AMQuote from: WAcoyotehunter on May 18, 2016, 07:19:33 AMQuote from: Branden on May 15, 2016, 10:07:07 AMI'm not going to comment on the legalities of it because I was not there nor the one that got supposed permission to hunt that area. I do have a problem though with the part about how it's bad to shoot an animal in a field. Zero difference then shooting a cat out of a tree. Neither one takes any skill yet 99% of the people on this site would jump at the chance to shoot a lion in a tree. The first thread on this issue was started because guys were saying it wasn't much of a hunt. Not that it was illegal. Then that started after a page or two. So for the guys that are saying it's not hunting get off your high horse. You do a lot of hound hunting Brandon??oooo you beat me to it!he likely has never cougar hunted....I've been lucky enough to do many different hunts, including hunts in several other countries, cougar hunting is still my favorite hunt. Some of the best cougar hunts have ended by taking photos and leaving the cat in the tree! The most rewarding part is watching the young hounds learn and develop into experienced lion hounds. Almost anyone can become successful in many types of hunting, but to be a top notch hound hunter requires incredible dedication by the hunter and a very sharp learning curve. After all the time and work to get good at hound hunting, you can take your dogs to field, search for days and sometimes weeks to find a good track, you and your dogs can experience the thrill of the hunt, hopefully you catch the cat and get photos of the hunted, and then you leave the hunted animal unharmed in the wild after experiencing the hunt of lifetime. Hunting really can't get any better than that!For those that choose to notch a cougar tag you then have some of the best meat in the woods!
Quote from: WAcoyotehunter on May 18, 2016, 07:19:33 AMQuote from: Branden on May 15, 2016, 10:07:07 AMI'm not going to comment on the legalities of it because I was not there nor the one that got supposed permission to hunt that area. I do have a problem though with the part about how it's bad to shoot an animal in a field. Zero difference then shooting a cat out of a tree. Neither one takes any skill yet 99% of the people on this site would jump at the chance to shoot a lion in a tree. The first thread on this issue was started because guys were saying it wasn't much of a hunt. Not that it was illegal. Then that started after a page or two. So for the guys that are saying it's not hunting get off your high horse. You do a lot of hound hunting Brandon??oooo you beat me to it!
Quote from: Branden on May 15, 2016, 10:07:07 AMI'm not going to comment on the legalities of it because I was not there nor the one that got supposed permission to hunt that area. I do have a problem though with the part about how it's bad to shoot an animal in a field. Zero difference then shooting a cat out of a tree. Neither one takes any skill yet 99% of the people on this site would jump at the chance to shoot a lion in a tree. The first thread on this issue was started because guys were saying it wasn't much of a hunt. Not that it was illegal. Then that started after a page or two. So for the guys that are saying it's not hunting get off your high horse. You do a lot of hound hunting Brandon??
I'm not going to comment on the legalities of it because I was not there nor the one that got supposed permission to hunt that area. I do have a problem though with the part about how it's bad to shoot an animal in a field. Zero difference then shooting a cat out of a tree. Neither one takes any skill yet 99% of the people on this site would jump at the chance to shoot a lion in a tree. The first thread on this issue was started because guys were saying it wasn't much of a hunt. Not that it was illegal. Then that started after a page or two. So for the guys that are saying it's not hunting get off your high horse.