28 Desert Unit bucks taken by Yakima Indian Nation rumor or truth?

[huntnfmly]

Wow calling members who state the way they feel and their opinions about this subject  small minded and idiots all I can say is wow.
I know you're going to say you didn't use the word idiot but that's what you meant wow

[PlateauNDN]

There's an assortment of problems whether any of you care to acknowledge them or not. We are just one piece to the puzzle.

[Odell]

essentially he called anyone who disagrees with him retarded.

[JimmyHoffa]

There are not "numerous problems," at least not ones that are a subject of this thread. The problem is that the Yakama tribe and the WDFW do not work together in managing deer and elk. It makes no sense to have the Desert GMU with a very small number of permits each year for hunting mule deer for non tribal members, while the Yakama tribe allows their people to kill as many mule deer as they want out of the same unit. This applies to the Alkali GMU as well. That is the problem and that's what this thread is about. It's not about emotion and there's no lack of logic in what's being discussed.

And it isn't just not working together with Yakamas and mule deer.  A few other tribes that WDFW just doesn't seem willing to want to upset.  It could be about oh...not having a saltwater salmon season in most of 2016 while gill nets are full of fish to be sold in parking lots or on craig's list, or river boundary disputes that now exclude state fishermen yet WDFW has a hatchery on that river, or elk herds or crabbing, etc.....

[huntnfmly]

essentially he called anyone who disagrees with him retarded.

yes but I was being nice by not saying retarded.but you are correct

[Jpmiller]

Plat you keep alluding to some ideas without sharing them. I didn't have the opportunity to get to know clockumelk so I never heard any of these from him like you did. Is there any of his plan you can share with us or a thread I can get to with his ideas in them? The man is held in extremely high regard around here and I am very curious what he thought.

[Time Immemorial 1855]

The difference is that my ancestors hunted,fished and gathered in all these places and your did not

[bobcat]

The difference is that my ancestors hunted,fished and gathered in all these places and your did not

So we should kill all the deer until there's none left?

[DaveMonti]

Well, maybe "unable to comprehend the written word" would be a better way to describe some folks.  I did not say "people who have a problem with the tribal treaties" are small minded, or retarded, or ignorant.  I said "People who can't see the big picture" are small minded.  If you're going to blame me for something, please read and comprehend and get it right.

Yes, 30 years of problem solving have taught me that getting stuck on a "one solution" emotional issue is ineffective.  That's why I'm in the top of my profession, because I can see the big picture. 

Now, continue on...you've got a lot more emotional bashing to get out of your systems.  Commence. 

[huntnfmly]

The difference is that my ancestors hunted,fished and gathered in all these places and your did not

once again time perfect smart rear end reply

[PlateauNDN]

Jp, Dave touched on parts of it but basically utilizing science as a component and other factors to find solutions between both Nations. Not sitting around blaming each other and bashing.

He had the concept that there is many factors and here they are and here's solutions to tackle them.

[jackelope]

The difference is that my ancestors hunted,fished and gathered in all these places and your did not

I'm sure that lots of folks on here have parents, grandparents and great grandparents who hunted and fished here all their lives.

This doesn't justify a bottomless harvest at all. Not in the least.

[huntnfmly]

Hey Mr monti way to try and walk your statement back. Good for you for having the ego to tell everyone your at the top of your profession. Guess what so am I and lots of other members on here I'm  sure and I still don't call people small minded and that they can't comprehend my statements

[JimmyHoffa]

The difference is that my ancestors hunted,fished and gathered in all these places and your did not

I'm sure that lots of folks on here have parents, grandparents and great grandparents who hunted and fished here all their lives.

This doesn't justify a bottomless harvest at all. Not in the least.

And to note using the ancestral angle, for some tribes many are 1/4 Indian (some are even less). 

[rasbo]

maybe we should all go back where we came from,cause everybody migrated here,including the Indians..I really think its time to let the past go and be one nation,things would be much better