Score please...Nice 4x

[boneaddict]

I think Phool is pretty darn close, except for the eyeguards maybe.  Not sure that one will cut it, overall will probably be just short of 150 gross and will certainly net in the low mid 140s.  Glad to see he is still out there.  Not nearly as many survivors as I'd like to see.

[Pilot_Hunter]

Nice 5x

[boneaddict]

Nice 5x

      

[TriggerHappy]

137 to 135

[deaner]

okay so i have no idea what the formula is to come up with a score for a buck, can anybody break it down for me?

[boneaddict]

Phool pretty much did it

as for guessing on the hoof I guess that just comes from and measuring a bunch of bones

[deaner]

im not talking on the hoof, i want to know how to actually take a tape measure to a rack and figure it out.

[boneaddict]

gotcha

well that takes a little more explainin'

[deaner]

explain away i hgave time

[Holg3107]

http://www.boone-crockett.org/bgrecords/bc_scoring_pdfs.asp?area=bgRecords

Heres a good place to start on how to score an animal.

[Wacenturion]

Interesting thread.  May be easier to compare the buck in question to a 150 type buck.  For the sake of comparison here is an Okanogan buck I took with a muzzle loader in 1977.  Didn't have him scored until 2000 or 2001.  He scores....151 2/8

Another comparison between the buck in question and mine is inside spread.  This buck has the distinction of having the smallest inside spread in The Longhunter Society Book (Muzzleloader Records) at 14 2/8

In comparison the phools numbers....
My numbers                           phools numbers
22 1/8    21 7/8                     19     -    19
1 0/8       0                           1 4/8 - 1 4/8
16 7/8     17 0/8                    14     -    14
9 6/8       9 4/8                      8       -     7
4 4/8       5 3/8                      9       -     6
4 0/8       4 0/8                      4 2/8 - 4 2/8
4 0/8       4 0/8                      4       -     4
3 6/8       3 6/8                      3 6/8 - 3 6/8
4 0/8       4 0/8                      3 4/8 - 3 4/8
Spread credit 14 2/8               Spread credit 18
153 6/8 gross  151 2/8 net      148 gross  144 net                                                         

[wilsongideon]

Thats a great buck centurion I would definitly be proud to hang that on my wall!, But to me I would l say the buck I photo'd would stretch 150 then if your buck is one fifty ..maybe I am just confused but if heigth is similiar and mass, I would say the one on the hoof with a hair more inside spread and a little better front forks would score better.  Not trying to beat a couple more inches out of a buck none of us are going to score for real. just my 

That buck really is only 14 inches inside wow. lol

[Wea300mag]

I would go with 140 . . . . . . . . Grain Core-lokt

[huntnphool]

Thats a great buck centurion I would definitly be proud to hang that on my wall!, But to me I would l say the buck I photo'd would stretch 150 then if your buck is one fifty ..maybe I am just confused but if heigth is similiar and mass, I would say the one on the hoof with a hair more inside spread and a little better front forks would score better.  Not trying to beat a couple more inches out of a buck none of us are going to score for real. just my 

That buck really is only 14 inches inside wow. lol

I don't think so Wilson, most of the score comes from the mains and backs where his buck is clearly bigger.

[deaner]

so the link i got to the scoring process sounds pretty complicated...... how about some estimates for this guy?