
The truth is one should always carry. Why? Because the fact is, you just don't know. You do not know what you are going to face out there. Period. What is the old scout motto? Be prepared? One should be while spending time in the woods. Whether it's bears, cougars, tweakers, or just idiots. You NEVER know what could happen. And what if you trip or accidentally drop your rifle or muzzle loader or shot gun, or stumble and fill the barrel with mud? Now all you have is a heavy stick. As mentioned earlier I would rather carry and not need it, then not carry and need it. I'll even carry my little snub .38 with me even for short trips. A person's life and well being are worth far more than negligence.
True, chances are you will never need a weapon, but what if you do? Think you can play forest ninja and "Jackie Chan" a cougar or strung out tweakers into a submission hold? Would make a great movie, but is very doubtful. Guess it depends on what your comfortable with. If your kungfu is strong, and you graduated top honors at the school of Rambo, then no worries I guess

As for me I'll always carry a sidearm. Because really, ya never know!
