The 3 point restriction is not clear to me so I probably would have let that bull go, even though it's probably legal.
Here's what it says in the pamphlet: "A 3 pt. minimum elk means that a legal elk in these GMU's must have at least 3 antler points on one side, with at least 2 antler points above the ear. Eye guards are antler points when they are at least one inch long."