Which would you choose? help Make my choice easier.

[Mallardmasher]

Would you take the old papa or his son,

[Mallardmasher]

I think this must be his offspring, crab fronts are almost the same, and maybe what injured the old guys ear

[h20hunter]

Old papa

[Mallardmasher]

Old papa has good mass, son has more length and looking at left side appears to have some mass. Here is the old guy 1 hour after I left stand yesterday. Son came I. Two hours later. They had a knock down drag out at 5:40am while I was watching 14 yards away. Awsome

[Mallardmasher]

P.S rut is still going on, after fight old guy bred a doe. And 4 hours later a younger 3x4 with same grabs bred a doe right in front of me. I was 15’ up 14yds away. Again awsome.

[Boss .300 winmag]

Old papa

  

[andr3wxmma]

papa this year, son next.

[runamuk]

Whichever one was standing there during legal shooting days/hours.

[JakeLand]

Mass !!!!

[Jpmiller]

Whichever one was standing there during legal shooting days/hours.

My vote as well. Can't be disappointed with either.

[fishnfur]

Great spot to hunt.  Wish you had videos of those brawls.    I'd take the old one if given a choice.  He's likely not going to get any better.  The younger one might end up being better if given another year or two.

[biggfish]

I'm not into points or mass, so I'd thethe younger buck since both look mature. The younger buck will probably made for better table fare, but I wouldn't hesitate to drop either if a shot presents itself.

Sent from my LG-K425 using Tapatalk

[wheels]

old papa

[JWEBB]

Old Papa. He might not be around after this winter they are predicting

[fishngamereaper]

Are those near your house..I think Ive seen the bigger one walking around. Take the one that gives the most ethical shot. No guarantees either one will be around next year.

[erk444]

Both the first and second pics look like the same buck to me? racks are pretty much identical

[JakeLand]

Both the first and second pics look like the same buck to me? racks are pretty much identical

2 different bucks ear and mass on pic #1 is a good looking buck and the more spindly tined buck needs more time and he'll be good

[erk444]

Both the first and second pics look like the same buck to me? racks are pretty much identical

2 different bucks ear and mass on pic #1 is a good looking buck and the more spindly tined buck needs more time and he'll be good

Click on the second pic to enlarge it and look closer. Same tines, same bases, and same mass. Looks different cause of the picture quality and lack of color. Same buck.