Tightspot Quiver Foam insert vs. Rubber insert

[returnofsid]

I need to replace the foam insert, in my Tightspot Quiver.  Emailing Joe Jack, at Tightspot, I see that there's the foam replacement insert or a non foam rubber insert.  Any opinions on pros and cons of each?

[RadSav]

Foam wears out and traps water, but it's quieter and lighter in weight.  I like the foam myself.

[D-Rock425]

I like foam also

[RadSav]

Put your blades in the same way every time and it will last a good long time.

[Smossy]

I like just the rubber myself

[snarkybull]

i like the rubber.  don't really understand why people use foam.

[Annette]

I like the foam, mine works great!

[returnofsid]

Put your blades in the same way every time and it will last a good long time.

That's my plan.  Unfortunately, the foam was already all sliced up, from the previous owner.