Real Geese Vs Big Als Silhouettes thoughts?

[Everydaylimits]

What does everyone else think of these? This is my comparison and unboxing video below:

[h2ofowlr]

Real Geese I have are fairly heavy.  They are a solid mylar or plastic.  The Big Al's I have are like the political signs.  Coorigated plastic.  Light to pack and they look fairly good.  What I use more often are new Divebomb decoys.  If you get the goose ones, get the flocked heads.  I have them in mallards, wigeon and goose.  They seem to work well until they don't, then I bring out the full bodies when the birds smarten up to much for the sihouettes.

[Stein]

I haven't tried Big Al's, but I can confirm if you put the Real Geese where the geese don't want to be that they don't magically pull them from the sky.  Honestly, I don't think the geese care one brand from the next, it's more about what is on sale and what is easy to pack in, set up and not break.