Free: Contests & Raffles.
I'm going into year 4 on my Lowa Tibets. Best boot I've owned so far, never had a wet foot in them. Couple those boots with some outdoor research crocodile gaiters, and I'm confident in any situation, including wading across creeks deeper then the boot is tall.
When your feet sweat like a 400lb woman on a treadmill staying dry isn't an option. Staying warm is what I work for.
It seems like consistency or rather, a lack of it, is a common denominator in all of the boot brands. My experience is if its not rubber or neoprene its time to failure is ticking as soon as it comes out of the box. I never get boots in general to last longer than 2 seasons (especially if i am active shed hunting) so if they make it that far I consider it a success. I also believe from anecdotal evidence foot shape and how you walk plays a factor, as I have swore off both tibet and kenny mountain extremes, as pairs leaked within day one, yet crispi boots in general have been good to me, and plenty of opinions say they should not be. I have had good luck with hanwag, zamberlin, and early meindle as well. All leather boots will saturate eventually. If multiple days of wet feet are planned, and rubber boots are out, I buy a half size up and run a few pairs of thin wool socks topped with sealskinz. That is the closest i have gotten to multi day dry feet when everyday is wet with no option to dry.