Bumping or Nile...

[bench beast]

which area has the better hunting for BIG BULLS

[buglebuster]

Neither with no special permit 

[Raul Duke]

BOTH

[D-Rock425]

It depends on your style of hunting.  Both have good bulls.

[gasman]

It depends on your style of hunting.  Both have good bulls.

 

[bench beast]

Neither with no special permit 

I have a archery permit

[wsucowboy]

It depends on your style of hunting.  Both have good bulls.

 

X2

[400out]

I wuold say Nile, but on the other hand Bumping has a lot of logging done lately so there is more land that is easier to sit and glass. But you need weather or horses 

[rtspring]

I would say NILE,

I have seen good numbers of elk in there over the years, this was a hotspot years ago. Never bow hunted it but you should get into some good numbers of elk..

good luck

[deerslyr]

Both units have great bulls but id personally pick bumping

[yajsab]

Bumping. Less road, less people.

[bench beast]

are the BULLS Talkin good in early sept. Can they be called in, or should I plan on spot and stalk.

[BENCHLEG]

  have fun.

[boneaddict]

Varies every year.

Equal animals for the most part.

[JLS]

are the BULLS Talkin good in early sept. Can they be called in, or should I plan on spot and stalk.

I'd practice on your callingas much as you can, but don't make that your only bag of tricks.