Phil Robertson - Banned from A & E

[BIGINNER]

Comparing homosexuality to beastality is beyond comprehension. That is pure BS. I'm glad he's off the air. You speak your mind? Fine, but the people signing your paycheck don't have to like it.

WHERE THE HELL ARE YOU GUYS GETTING THIS?

THE INTERVIEWER ASKED HIM WHAT SIN IS,... HE ANSWERED: (NOT EXACT QUOTE, BUT CLOSE) "WELL START WITH HOMOSEXUALITY, THEN WARP OUT FROM THERE, BEASTEALITY, TERRORISM, SLEEPING AROING WITH THIS WOMEN AND THAT WOMEN, AND THAT MAN IT'S JUST WRONG MAN"   
CONTEXT  GUYS, CONTEXT... 

[Nailed it]

Grandpa, looks like your the one comparing them

[scout/sniper]

soooo.....homosexuality and sleeping with women are the same thing?
Or is sleeping with women an act of terrorism.   

[motg9_6]

i discriminate!!! no more a&e for me

[runamuk]

soooo.....homosexuality and sleeping with women are the same thing?
Or is sleeping with women an act of terrorism.   

well pretty sure if I was sleeping with women it would be  just saying...... seems this context concept is really important....no?

[scout/sniper]

soooo.....homosexuality and sleeping with women are the same thing?
Or is sleeping with women an act of terrorism.   

well pretty sure if I was sleeping with women it would be  just saying...... seems this context concept is really important....no?

People see what they want to see.

[BIGINNER]

soooo.....homosexuality and sleeping with women are the same thing?
Or is sleeping with women an act of terrorism.   

HE WAS NAMING SINS. HOMOSEXUALITY IS A SIN, BEASEALITY IS A SIN, SLEAPING AROUND WITH WOMEN (SLEAPING WITH WOMEN THAT AREN'T YOUR WIFE) IS A SIN. SLEAPING WITH A MAN (FOR WOMEN) THAT ISN'T YOUR HUSBAND IS A SIN.......    THEY ASKED HIM WHAT IS SIN, ....... HE STATED WHAT SIN IS BASED ON THE BIBLE....

[runamuk]

soooo.....homosexuality and sleeping with women are the same thing?
Or is sleeping with women an act of terrorism.   

well pretty sure if I was sleeping with women it would be  just saying...... seems this context concept is really important....no?

People see what they want to see.

hear what they want to hear, believe what they want to believe... its partly why I dont get too involved in all the movie star hype and checkstand magazine drama which is what this is basically a bunch of rich and famous sorts arguing over things that are based mostly in the land of make believe anyway.

[scout/sniper]

soooo.....homosexuality and sleeping with women are the same thing?
Or is sleeping with women an act of terrorism.   

HE WAS NAMING SINS. HOMOSEXUALITY IS A SIN, BEASEALITY IS A SIN, SLEAPING AROUND WITH WOMEN (SLAPING WITH WOMEN THAT AREN'T YOUR WIFE) IS A SIN. SLEAPING WITH A MAN (FOR WOMEN) THAT ISN'T YOUR HUSBAND IS A SIN.......    THEY ASKED HIM WHAT IS SIN, ....... HE WAS STATED WHAT SIN IS BASED ON THE BIBLE....

I know.
He made a list. He didn't compare any of them to each other.

[BIGINNER]

soooo.....homosexuality and sleeping with women are the same thing?
Or is sleeping with women an act of terrorism.   

HE WAS NAMING SINS. HOMOSEXUALITY IS A SIN, BEASEALITY IS A SIN, SLEAPING AROUND WITH WOMEN (SLAPING WITH WOMEN THAT AREN'T YOUR WIFE) IS A SIN. SLEAPING WITH A MAN (FOR WOMEN) THAT ISN'T YOUR HUSBAND IS A SIN.......    THEY ASKED HIM WHAT IS SIN, ....... HE WAS STATED WHAT SIN IS BASED ON THE BIBLE....

I know.
He made a list. He didn't compare any of them to each other.

YES,.... SO, IF YOU GOT THAT PART,... WHY THE QUESTION? 

[scout/sniper]

soooo.....homosexuality and sleeping with women are the same thing?
Or is sleeping with women an act of terrorism.   

HE WAS NAMING SINS. HOMOSEXUALITY IS A SIN, BEASEALITY IS A SIN, SLEAPING AROUND WITH WOMEN (SLAPING WITH WOMEN THAT AREN'T YOUR WIFE) IS A SIN. SLEAPING WITH A MAN (FOR WOMEN) THAT ISN'T YOUR HUSBAND IS A SIN.......    THEY ASKED HIM WHAT IS SIN, ....... HE WAS STATED WHAT SIN IS BASED ON THE BIBLE....

I know.
He made a list. He didn't compare any of them to each other.

YES,.... SO, IF YOU GOT THAT PART,... WHY THE QUESTION? 

Highlighting the other ways that people could associate the comments.
It wasn't literal.

[runamuk]

soooo.....homosexuality and sleeping with women are the same thing?
Or is sleeping with women an act of terrorism.   

HE WAS NAMING SINS. HOMOSEXUALITY IS A SIN, BEASEALITY IS A SIN, SLEAPING AROUND WITH WOMEN (SLAPING WITH WOMEN THAT AREN'T YOUR WIFE) IS A SIN. SLEAPING WITH A MAN (FOR WOMEN) THAT ISN'T YOUR HUSBAND IS A SIN.......    THEY ASKED HIM WHAT IS SIN, ....... HE WAS STATED WHAT SIN IS BASED ON THE BIBLE....

I know.
He made a list. He didn't compare any of them to each other.

YES,.... SO, IF YOU GOT THAT PART,... WHY THE QUESTION? 

Highlighting the other ways that people could associate the comments.
It wasn't literal.

It was rhetorical and related to the idea of context...heck I got it and I am a very literal person...everything thats been said and argued at this point has all been taken out of context without the ENTIRE conversation in whole in writing it is easy to pick and choose what one wants to focus on and how they want to interpret it.

[scout/sniper]

soooo.....homosexuality and sleeping with women are the same thing?
Or is sleeping with women an act of terrorism.   

HE WAS NAMING SINS. HOMOSEXUALITY IS A SIN, BEASEALITY IS A SIN, SLEAPING AROUND WITH WOMEN (SLAPING WITH WOMEN THAT AREN'T YOUR WIFE) IS A SIN. SLEAPING WITH A MAN (FOR WOMEN) THAT ISN'T YOUR HUSBAND IS A SIN.......    THEY ASKED HIM WHAT IS SIN, ....... HE WAS STATED WHAT SIN IS BASED ON THE BIBLE....

I know.
He made a list. He didn't compare any of them to each other.

YES,.... SO, IF YOU GOT THAT PART,... WHY THE QUESTION? 

Highlighting the other ways that people could associate the comments.
It wasn't literal.

It was rhetorical and related to the idea of context...heck I got it and I am a very literal person...everything thats been said and argued at this point has all been taken out of context without the ENTIRE conversation in whole in writing it is easy to pick and choose what one wants to focus on and how they want to interpret it.

BINGO!!

[BIGINNER]

soooo.....homosexuality and sleeping with women are the same thing?
Or is sleeping with women an act of terrorism.   

HE WAS NAMING SINS. HOMOSEXUALITY IS A SIN, BEASEALITY IS A SIN, SLEAPING AROUND WITH WOMEN (SLAPING WITH WOMEN THAT AREN'T YOUR WIFE) IS A SIN. SLEAPING WITH A MAN (FOR WOMEN) THAT ISN'T YOUR HUSBAND IS A SIN.......    THEY ASKED HIM WHAT IS SIN, ....... HE WAS STATED WHAT SIN IS BASED ON THE BIBLE....

I know.
He made a list. He didn't compare any of them to each other.

YES,.... SO, IF YOU GOT THAT PART,... WHY THE QUESTION? 

Highlighting the other ways that people could associate the comments.
It wasn't literal.

OH. SORRY

[scout/sniper]

soooo.....homosexuality and sleeping with women are the same thing?
Or is sleeping with women an act of terrorism.   

HE WAS NAMING SINS. HOMOSEXUALITY IS A SIN, BEASEALITY IS A SIN, SLEAPING AROUND WITH WOMEN (SLAPING WITH WOMEN THAT AREN'T YOUR WIFE) IS A SIN. SLEAPING WITH A MAN (FOR WOMEN) THAT ISN'T YOUR HUSBAND IS A SIN.......    THEY ASKED HIM WHAT IS SIN, ....... HE WAS STATED WHAT SIN IS BASED ON THE BIBLE....

I know.
He made a list. He didn't compare any of them to each other.

YES,.... SO, IF YOU GOT THAT PART,... WHY THE QUESTION? 

Highlighting the other ways that people could associate the comments.
It wasn't literal.

OH. SORRY

  You're a little fired-up, I wasn't trying to push your buttons.