P & Y Whitetails

[OutHouse]

Who here has a P & Y whitetail they can show me? It's my goal to get one someday. Please tell me the score of it if you know or can approximate. Also, any other record book eligible bucks of any kind are welcome, Thanks!

[buckfvr]

Not being a dick here at all, but Id get the book for the pictures and the scores so you can see the most common attributes of a deer that makes minimum.  You will se that a lot of them share similar mass and main beam length and you will get to where you can discount an animal based on a quick observation, at least to the point of "likely to make it" and "unlikely to make it". 

The book will allow you to compare pics to scores easily and handily at your convenience.   

[lewy]

Crappy picture but here’s one I killed that would be about what it takes to get you close

[trophyhunt]

Crappy picture but here’s one I killed that would be about what it takes to get you close

Man, you can barely tell you photo shopped your pic over mine!!! 







 

[OutHouse]

Not being a dick here at all, but Id get the book for the pictures and the scores so you can see the most common attributes of a deer that makes minimum.  You will se that a lot of them share similar mass and main beam length and you will get to where you can discount an animal based on a quick observation, at least to the point of "likely to make it" and "unlikely to make it". 

The book will allow you to compare pics to scores easily and handily at your convenience.   

No that's great advice I hadn't even thought to buy the book itself. I'll have to do that thanks

[OutHouse]

Crappy picture but here’s one I killed that would be about what it takes to get you close

Thanks Lewy! It can be so hard to judge them with the little experience I have in that regard. My taxi showed me one that was 7/8 above the minimum and it looked achievable in my area. I think that buck had four points and the eye guards. From my recollection your buck should definitely meet the minimum if not more but again, little experience etc.

[lastmk8]

Being that I've never scored a deer, I don't think I've ever thought about it.  Here is a WT I shot a few years back, I wasn't even thinking about having it mounted (as you can tell by my cut lines) until most that stopped by camp said that in one dandy of a buck off this mountain.  Anyway, I never had it scored, but wonder anyone's thoughts on him (Fred, the dead deer).  I've never hunted for numbers, but had I would this fella be in the ball park??

[Skyvalhunter]

That's a nice younger buck

[BULLBLASTER]

Add up the numbers to see what it takes to get there. Your looking at 55 inches per side with a 15 inch spread to get to 125. A good estimate for mass on most mature whitetails is 15 ish inches.

[OutHouse]

Pretty sure that would make the cut great buck lastmk8

[BULLBLASTER]

These all make it with room to spare by score. Only 2 are bow kills tho.

[DOUBLELUNG]

Buck on the right nets 125, 4 point on the left is shy 119 IIRC.  Obviously NOT archery kills

[blindluck]

163” mulie has 39” mass

[OutHouse]

Nice! Thank you all for these

[emac]

These all make it with room to spare by score. Only 2 are bow kills tho.

Do you think those 1st 2 bucks were related the look very similar

Sent from my SM-G935V using Tapatalk

[BULLBLASTER]

These all make it with room to spare by score. Only 2 are bow kills tho.

Do you think those 1st 2 bucks were related the look very similar

Sent from my SM-G935V using Tapatalk

Mostly just the picture angles make them look that way. They were a long ways apart from each other. The hard horned one was much wider and not near as tall as the velvet. And the velvet had a few extras.

[Tjv28]

Hey Blindluck, is your buck 163” net? It seems much bigger gross? Stunning buck regardless

[OutHouse]

Hey Blindluck, is your buck 163” net? It seems much bigger gross? Stunning buck regardless

Serioulsy, that beam on the front right in the picture looks like a swollen banana, maybe even a plantain!

[blindluck]

Hey Blindluck, is your buck 163” net? It seems much bigger gross? Stunning buck regardless

I know, I had one guy that saw it in person guess 190”. He scores 163” gross. Something about his heaviness is deceiving.

[coonhound]

This guy scored 178 gross

[Doublelunger]

<---- my profile picture are both pope and young whitetail taken here in WA. 164" and 163".

[huntnnw]

Hey Blindluck, is your buck 163” net? It seems much bigger gross? Stunning buck regardless

I know, I had one guy that saw it in person guess 190”. He scores 163” gross. Something about his heaviness is deceiving.

Nets are for fish

[OutHouse]

I remember seeing that one a while back coonhound what a trophy! And same to you doublelunger those two mounts look great!

[OutHouse]

Hey Blindluck, is your buck 163” net? It seems much bigger gross? Stunning buck regardless

I know, I had one guy that saw it in person guess 190”. He scores 163” gross. Something about his heaviness is deceiving.

Nets are for fish

Hey man, from my review of this site over the years I know you gotta have a bunch that qualify. If you would indulge us post up a few. Thanks!

[Doublelunger]

Hey Blindluck, is your buck 163” net? It seems much bigger gross? Stunning buck regardless

I know, I had one guy that saw it in person guess 190”. He scores 163” gross. Something about his heaviness is deceiving.

Nets are for fish

Hey man, from my review of this site over the years I know you gotta have a bunch that qualify. If you would indulge us post up a few. Thanks!

He doesn't mess with dinky P&Y bucks,  he goes strait for the Booners he just gets em with archery take tackle.

[blindluck]

Hey Blindluck, is your buck 163” net? It seems much bigger gross? Stunning buck regardless

I know, I had one guy that saw it in person guess 190”. He scores 163” gross. Something about his heaviness is deceiving.

Nets are for fish

you might of seen this one already

Hey man, from my review of this site over the years I know you gotta have a bunch that qualify. If you would indulge us post up a few. Thanks!

[bigmuliebuck]

 

[OutHouse]

Steep and deed blindluck thanks for sharing that awesome mule!

[huntnnw]

This buck grossed right at 150

[OutHouse]

Jeez!! Long tines on that bad boy thanks for sharing

[Skyvalhunter]

This buck grossed right at 150

nice animal, Did you strip the velvet off?

[huntnnw]

No, had it freeze dried

[Skyvalhunter]

That turned out pretty cool unique