Choices...Muley V Whitetail

[boneaddict]

[Toptwo]

Whitey, no doubt!

[lokidog]

I would hope my son was with me and on three... boom, boom....     I might have to just flip a coin if I was by myself.

[PlateauNDN]

I've never tasted whitey so I'd take him.

[Holg3107]

While the whitetail is a better representative of the species. I have a handful of 150" whitetail already and no Mule deer over a few smaller buck so the mule deer gets the lead for me. That said, I would probably second guess myself if the situation actually came along. Both great deer!

[buckfvr]

I think a guy would stand a better chance of finding another mule buck as good as that if he passed and took the whitetail......may never get a chance at another whitetail like that, and he is most likely peaked.

[Killmore]

Neither, they would run away before I could make my mind up.

[quadrafire]

The WT, the mulie is on the wrong side of the fence.

[rover758]

The whitetail fur sure and fur certain.

[C-Money]

I just killed a good whitetail last year. I have looked for a nice 4pt mule deer for a long time, but keep finding 3pts. I'd take the muley.

[Rainier10]

Whitetail for me, I have a few muleys on the wall, the whitetail would break things up a bit.  Not to mention they are way better table fare.

[Tpetie3509]

I'm gonna go against the grain on this one and say the muley, look at that symmetry! That whitetail is amazing though. Awesome picture!

[h20hunter]

You know....we need our own Hunt-Wa lottery. Each year any forum member that wants to participate puts $50 in the pot. Mid summer rolls around and one name is drawn. The winner...say myself...then gets to follow Bone around for a week to see if they can find an elk/whitetail/muley/bear......and then kill it. The total pot goes to forum servers/charity whatever.

[1bugman]

Got a nice white tail in 04. Still looking for a nice Muley

[Toptwo]

You know....we need our own Hunt-Wa lottery. Each year any forum member that wants to participate puts $50 in the pot. Mid summer rolls around and one name is drawn. The winner...say myself...then gets to follow Bone around for a week to see if they can find an elk/whitetail/muley/bear......and then kill it. The total pot goes to forum servers/charity whatever.

  Say What?!?!?

But... I DO like that Idea and I, for one, would send in my $50!