Free: Contests & Raffles.
So...there are so many different kinds of elk hunts that certain things may be important during one season, and almost irrelevant during another. 10 day backpack archery hunts demand different things than November rifle hunts. I've been to an awful lot of funerals for elk in my life, from August to January and 400 to 10,000 ft., and my advice would be this; 1.) Understand elk behaviorUnderstanding where elk want to be when the weather is X, the hunting pressure is Y, the terrain is Z, etc. is really the paramount thing a hunter needs to know to consistently kill elk. Once you really know elk behavior, someone can drop you off anywhere from New Mexico to Montana to Nevada and you can quickly solve the puzzle. Everything else you mention revolves around this point, and while you can learn quite a bit from reading and talking to other people, experience will be your best teacher.2.) Familiarity/experience in the hunting areaI know people who can consistently kill elk in certain areas because they've learned a spot, but because they don't hunt different places much if at all they haven't connected the dots.3a, b, c, d, e...) pre hunt planning, physical fitness, ability to shoot, calling ability, etc. all have there place and importance depending on what type of hunt you are doing, but number 1 is the key. No matter how good you are at the rest of it, you can't kill an elk you can't find.
Roll out 2 hrs before legal light, hunt all day, come back way after dark, repeat till done.
Knowing your area and how the elk use it is the key IMO. one of the biggest elk slayers I know is 73 years old in ok shape for his age and has been hunting the same area his whole life. He doesn't have to hike far to kill elk because he knows the area so well and filled both his tags this year. The other elk slayer I know is 55 smokes a pack of marb reds a day (don't recommend or promote this) and filled both of his elk tags this year. been hunting the same area for 20 years.Now here's the kicker. I consider a good elk hunter some one who can go to the same spot every year and kill an elk.I consider a GREAT elk hunter some one who can go to any unit any time and kill an elk. This is where fitness, general elk behavior, weapon knowledge etc comes into play big time.
knowledge of the area you are hunting and how the elk move around in those area's are big in my categories. Which I think takes years to learn. And Not waiting around for 20 years for a tag helps!!
Some people are just hunters , the way they stalk and think and the drive to do what ever it takes . I always told people you have to hunt elk where they are not where you want to hunt , no matter where that may be or how crappy it will be to get one out . there is only so many of hours to hunt don't leave any on the table .
Quote from: coachcw on January 29, 2015, 02:18:08 PMSome people are just hunters , the way they stalk and think and the drive to do what ever it takes . I always told people you have to hunt elk where they are not where you want to hunt , no matter where that may be or how crappy it will be to get one out . there is only so many of hours to hunt don't leave any on the table . I know some guys who hunt pretty hard but they just can't connect the dots. There are only so many hunters in a tribe, comes to mind.
Quote from: BLRman on January 29, 2015, 03:31:41 PMQuote from: coachcw on January 29, 2015, 02:18:08 PMSome people are just hunters , the way they stalk and think and the drive to do what ever it takes . I always told people you have to hunt elk where they are not where you want to hunt , no matter where that may be or how crappy it will be to get one out . there is only so many of hours to hunt don't leave any on the table . I know some guys who hunt pretty hard but they just can't connect the dots. There are only so many hunters in a tribe, comes to mind.How many years have those guys been hunting hard? Takes some time to learn an area and be able to consistently get opportunities. I hunted hard for four years going all over the state. Northeast, eastern wa, central wa, northwest and southwest. I would hunt hard. A lot harder than I hunt now. And my opportunities those years were very rare. After I settled on an area and actually started learning about elk I can get a shot op more times than not what I do at the moment of truth is a differnt story. Pre season was a huge factor in learning how to locate the elk. Shooting the bow all year. Even if it's only ten arrows over a month. Keeps me in form. Being addicted to elk hunting is what worked best for me. Next ridge next ridge next ridge repeat till you have elk down.
Sometimes it's not about boot leather. If you hunt in areas with very small and elusive herds, you need to hunt only that small area but be so meticulous that it drives you crazy. In six years of hunting one area, I've had 3 shot opportunities and killed one elk, it is a very small group of elk and if I were to "burn boot leather" I would blow them out or walk 10 miles past them.So far, the closest comparison to elk hunting is blacktail hunting. I've never heard a successful blacktail hunter say, "I've put on 60 miles the past two weeks and still no blacktail. No, people like BH45 have great spots and the revisit them. They are little areas that hold big bucks. That's what elk hunting is like to me. Every time I have tried to put mad miles on, I blow out elk and see nothing.
Quote from: Jonathan_S on January 29, 2015, 04:56:33 PMSometimes it's not about boot leather. If you hunt in areas with very small and elusive herds, you need to hunt only that small area but be so meticulous that it drives you crazy. In six years of hunting one area, I've had 3 shot opportunities and killed one elk, it is a very small group of elk and if I were to "burn boot leather" I would blow them out or walk 10 miles past them.So far, the closest comparison to elk hunting is blacktail hunting. I've never heard a successful blacktail hunter say, "I've put on 60 miles the past two weeks and still no blacktail. No, people like BH45 have great spots and the revisit them. They are little areas that hold big bucks. That's what elk hunting is like to me. Every time I have tried to put mad miles on, I blow out elk and see nothing. It is definitely very unique to different people and to different areas. Where one person excels, one person fails miserably. Sounds like I would not do well in your area The best hunters out there have all the skills to be able to adapt to any situation, area, or technique. I hope to one day make it to that level. I've got a very long way to go
Quote from: BLRman on January 29, 2015, 05:25:42 PMQuote from: Jonathan_S on January 29, 2015, 04:56:33 PMSometimes it's not about boot leather. If you hunt in areas with very small and elusive herds, you need to hunt only that small area but be so meticulous that it drives you crazy. In six years of hunting one area, I've had 3 shot opportunities and killed one elk, it is a very small group of elk and if I were to "burn boot leather" I would blow them out or walk 10 miles past them.So far, the closest comparison to elk hunting is blacktail hunting. I've never heard a successful blacktail hunter say, "I've put on 60 miles the past two weeks and still no blacktail. No, people like BH45 have great spots and the revisit them. They are little areas that hold big bucks. That's what elk hunting is like to me. Every time I have tried to put mad miles on, I blow out elk and see nothing. It is definitely very unique to different people and to different areas. Where one person excels, one person fails miserably. Sounds like I would not do well in your area The best hunters out there have all the skills to be able to adapt to any situation, area, or technique. I hope to one day make it to that level. I've got a very long way to go I'm right there with you! Got a long way to goMy natural tendency is to go full steam ahead but it's when I slowed down that I started killing animals more often.
Quote from: Jonathan_S on January 29, 2015, 05:27:40 PMQuote from: BLRman on January 29, 2015, 05:25:42 PMQuote from: Jonathan_S on January 29, 2015, 04:56:33 PMSometimes it's not about boot leather. If you hunt in areas with very small and elusive herds, you need to hunt only that small area but be so meticulous that it drives you crazy. In six years of hunting one area, I've had 3 shot opportunities and killed one elk, it is a very small group of elk and if I were to "burn boot leather" I would blow them out or walk 10 miles past them.So far, the closest comparison to elk hunting is blacktail hunting. I've never heard a successful blacktail hunter say, "I've put on 60 miles the past two weeks and still no blacktail. No, people like BH45 have great spots and the revisit them. They are little areas that hold big bucks. That's what elk hunting is like to me. Every time I have tried to put mad miles on, I blow out elk and see nothing. It is definitely very unique to different people and to different areas. Where one person excels, one person fails miserably. Sounds like I would not do well in your area The best hunters out there have all the skills to be able to adapt to any situation, area, or technique. I hope to one day make it to that level. I've got a very long way to go I'm right there with you! Got a long way to goMy natural tendency is to go full steam ahead but it's when I slowed down that I started killing animals more often. I'm always in awe at the true big dogs of the elk woods. I've learned more in the last two season's hunting with Coach than the last decade of grinding it out on my own. I have only eaten elk tag soup a few times but I still feel like a rookie. I feel like he has forgotten more about elk hunting than I will ever know
Quote from: BLRman on January 29, 2015, 05:54:59 PMQuote from: Jonathan_S on January 29, 2015, 05:27:40 PMQuote from: BLRman on January 29, 2015, 05:25:42 PMQuote from: Jonathan_S on January 29, 2015, 04:56:33 PMSometimes it's not about boot leather. If you hunt in areas with very small and elusive herds, you need to hunt only that small area but be so meticulous that it drives you crazy. In six years of hunting one area, I've had 3 shot opportunities and killed one elk, it is a very small group of elk and if I were to "burn boot leather" I would blow them out or walk 10 miles past them.So far, the closest comparison to elk hunting is blacktail hunting. I've never heard a successful blacktail hunter say, "I've put on 60 miles the past two weeks and still no blacktail. No, people like BH45 have great spots and the revisit them. They are little areas that hold big bucks. That's what elk hunting is like to me. Every time I have tried to put mad miles on, I blow out elk and see nothing. It is definitely very unique to different people and to different areas. Where one person excels, one person fails miserably. Sounds like I would not do well in your area The best hunters out there have all the skills to be able to adapt to any situation, area, or technique. I hope to one day make it to that level. I've got a very long way to go I'm right there with you! Got a long way to goMy natural tendency is to go full steam ahead but it's when I slowed down that I started killing animals more often. I'm always in awe at the true big dogs of the elk woods. I've learned more in the last two season's hunting with Coach than the last decade of grinding it out on my own. I have only eaten elk tag soup a few times but I still feel like a rookie. I feel like he has forgotten more about elk hunting than I will ever know Coach kills 380 bulls next to roads!! Thats all skill
Quote from: rtspring on January 29, 2015, 06:03:35 PMQuote from: BLRman on January 29, 2015, 05:54:59 PMQuote from: Jonathan_S on January 29, 2015, 05:27:40 PMQuote from: BLRman on January 29, 2015, 05:25:42 PMQuote from: Jonathan_S on January 29, 2015, 04:56:33 PMSometimes it's not about boot leather. If you hunt in areas with very small and elusive herds, you need to hunt only that small area but be so meticulous that it drives you crazy. In six years of hunting one area, I've had 3 shot opportunities and killed one elk, it is a very small group of elk and if I were to "burn boot leather" I would blow them out or walk 10 miles past them.So far, the closest comparison to elk hunting is blacktail hunting. I've never heard a successful blacktail hunter say, "I've put on 60 miles the past two weeks and still no blacktail. No, people like BH45 have great spots and the revisit them. They are little areas that hold big bucks. That's what elk hunting is like to me. Every time I have tried to put mad miles on, I blow out elk and see nothing. It is definitely very unique to different people and to different areas. Where one person excels, one person fails miserably. Sounds like I would not do well in your area The best hunters out there have all the skills to be able to adapt to any situation, area, or technique. I hope to one day make it to that level. I've got a very long way to go I'm right there with you! Got a long way to goMy natural tendency is to go full steam ahead but it's when I slowed down that I started killing animals more often. I'm always in awe at the true big dogs of the elk woods. I've learned more in the last two season's hunting with Coach than the last decade of grinding it out on my own. I have only eaten elk tag soup a few times but I still feel like a rookie. I feel like he has forgotten more about elk hunting than I will ever know Coach kills 380 bulls next to roads!! Thats all skill heck hike 200 miles to get them close to a road. Any time you think you have elk figured out you get burned. Elk adapt well and don't like human contact. I remember wearing elk decoys we made holding them up and sneaking in on elk. I have been really fortunate to be able to harvest fourty or so elk in 24 years or so. You learn something on everyone. The one constant in every archery hunt was the wind it is the single most important factor. Guys like blrman are taking the torch and carrying on . I feel like I can still get after it but no where near the way I could at 30. It used to be all about harvest in my 20s and 30s that has shifted a bit in the last few. I can't remember how many times in the last twenty years I took off in the direction away from elk near dark and ended up back at camp well after dark . I believe sitting on stand can be effective but it's not for me , I just don't get the same satisfaction from it . One other tip for still hunting is to look as far off as possible then scan back to you. You must see the elk first. As far as scouting I be leave it's good to a point and from distance . I think way to many guys are getting to close to elk and educating them . Scouting in a area that gets hit hard typically works opening day . I have seen guys that scouted and planned get really bummed by day two or three when all there preparation dosnt pay off. Hunt hard and try new things call at times and don't be afraid to blow it . My motto has been if you know where he is and the wind is good go for it now !
I really hope some of the newer elk hunters (or even those who have been hunting for years but do not consistently get shot opportunities each year) are taking notes. I have this thread running on three hunting forums and am really getting some great input. Once the threads run their course, I'll capsulate everthing and post.